logo for best-norman-rockwell-art.com

IT DEFINITELY IS NOT RACIST

by Mike Oldy

Roughly, 15 or more years ago Amtrak was looking into the possibility of using "Boy In Dining Car." as an advertisement. Since a heavy weight diner is shown in the painting; Amtrak would have probably preferred a more modern or streamlined car. This would, of course, have involved a lot of legalities.


A copy of the original painting was passed around and it caused some African Americans to vehemently say that it was racist. The reason, I guess, had something to do with servitude or, possibly, reinforce the negative stereotype that would have been in place in 1946.

The waiter is simply smiling; unseen by the little boy counting his change so that he might tip the waiter. Had the child given a tip that was small; we can be assured that the waiter would have thanked the boy profusely.

Back in 1946 the majority of dining car waiters were Black and doubtless served mostly white people; who could afford to eat in the diner. I do not meant to imply that people of color were all poor and thus would not have eaten in the diner. Since this was a New York Central diner; there would not have been Jim Crow laws, as in parts of the South wherein "colored" folks would have been the last to be served, plus a dividing curtain would have separated the two races.

In summary it is my considered opinion that this wonderful Norman Rockwell painting is not racist. To say that it is, is absolutely ludicrous.

Mike

From Keith: Thanks for your opinion, Mike. We do know that, without a doubt, Norman Rockwell was not a racist, so he would not knowingly paint a racist painting. He documented his world with gratitude, humility and a sense of wonder.

Click here to post comments

Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How? Simply click here to return to Boy in Dining Car.



Remember to check back often.

Rockwell Favorites

Doctor and the Doll
Buy it from Art.com - Click to Buy
Doctor and the Doll
Santa at His Desk
Buy it from Art.com - Click to Buy
Santa at His Desk
Before the Shot
Buy it from Art.com - Click to Buy
Before the Shot
Game Called Because of Rain
Buy it from Art.com - Click to Buy
Game Called Because of Rain (Three Umpires)
Freedom of Speech
Buy it from Art.com - Click to Buy
Freedom of Speech
Freedom from Want
Buy it from Art.com - Click to Buy
Freedom from Want
No Swimming
Buy it from Art.com - Click to Buy
No Swimming
The Runaway
Buy it from Art.com - Click to Buy
The Runaway
Girl at the Mirror
Buy it from Art.com - Click to Buy
Girl at the Mirror
Tattoo Artist
Buy it from Art.com - Click to Buy
Tattoo Artist
Puppy Love
Buy it from Art.com - Click to Buy
Puppy Love
(Little Spooners)

Norman Rockwell Christmas and Norman Rockwell Thanksgiving Galleries are open.

Norman Rockwell's painting, A Drum for Tommy or Santa with Drum, appeared on the cover of The Country Gentleman on 12/17/1921
Norman Rockwell Santa Claus
Gallery is open!







Copyright © Best Norman Rockwell Art.com.
Images are copyrighted by their respective copyright holders.
Graphic Files Protected by Digimarc.
Contact us for details about using our articles on your website.
The only requirements are an acknowledgement and a link.
Page copy protected against web site content infringement by Copyscape
AddThis Social Bookmark Button
Home | Donate | About | Contact | FAQ | Share | Search | Survey | Wanted
Sitemap | Sitemap, 2 | Sitemap, 3 | Sitemap, 4 | Privacy Policy | Disclaimer
My Business "Secret Weapon"